Judge, Jury, and Executioner

Lisa Thomas • September 7, 2017

You see it on Facebook all the time, people who are posting their rant of the day because something somewhere didn’t go to suit them.  Occasionally though, you’ll find someone who has tried their best to deal with the mess they’ve been handed but has finally reached their breaking point and Facebook seems the only safe way to vent.  And, on even fewer occasions, that venting stems from grief and is directed toward someone who has very little comprehension of the ventor’s suffering . . . but that didn’t stop them from weighing in on the “quality” and “appropriateness” of the other person’s grieving.

So, here’s a news flash—actually, several news flashes.  Not everyone who is grieving mopes around and cries  every time you talk to them.  Not everyone who is grieving is so obsessed with their loss that nothing else matters.  Not everyone who is grieving refuses to eat, loses weight, can’t sleep, or withdraws from life.  If you’re going to describe grief, the only statement that will hold true in every circumstance is that it’s personal.  Grief is different for everyone and that difference is determined by a host of factors including, but most certainly not limited to, your age and prior life experiences, the age of the deceased, the cause of the death, the depth of the relationship, and any residual guilt the survivor may be harboring.  And folks, that’s only the beginning.

But some well-meaning individuals—or busy bodies whose noses have a terrible time staying on their faces and out of everyone else’s business (take your pick)—have a need to observe and then condemn.  They become the judge by laying out their own set of rules for grieving.  As the jury they observe the one who is suffering from loss with the intent of determining their degree of compliance with the aforementioned rules.  And when that person—who may already be drowning in a sea of despair—fails to meet their standards, they don the black hood of the executioner and whisper behind their back about their happy face, or stolen moment of joy, or lifestyle after loss.  Worse yet, they may confront that struggling soul over what they perceive to be disrespect for the person who has died.  So, why don’t we just see if we can make their life even more miserable?

If I sound angry or disturbed—or both—it’s because I am.  I have never successfully read anyone’s mind or heart.  I have never successfully walked a mile in their shoes and I will never be able to.  Many people who are grieving struggle just to function, so when they find a moment where life will allow them to smile, I have no right to condemn it.  I don’t know how many other moments passed before that one arrived.  If they have the opportunity to enjoy themselves, no matter for how long, I have no right to find fault.  I don’t know how many hours they have cried or wrestled with the loneliness.  So I have a very difficult time understanding how some people simply cannot understand.

Hopefully the next time you see someone that you know is trudging through grief, you’ll smile with them when they feel they can.  Hopefully you’ll be grateful when they find a moment of joy instead of insisting that moment be stifled.  Someday when—not if, but when —you are required to travel the same path, you will want that same compassion from others.  Just don’t expect it if you aren’t willing to give it.

By Lisa Thomas December 4, 2025
It was one of those family-gathering occasions, the kind where the house is filled with laughter and conversations and at least two children running wild.
By Lisa Thomas November 20, 2025
A few weeks ago I was supposed to be in Memphis, spending a considerable amount of time in the great outdoors, specifically in cemeteries (which, if I can’t be in the middle of a forest, is the next best thing). According to the weather on my handy, dandy phone, this was not advisable.
By Lisa Thomas November 13, 2025
It’s that time of year. The time when we drag our traditions out of the closets and boxes and begin spreading them about the house. When recipes and recollections join together to create new memories or give life to old ones.
By Lisa Thomas November 5, 2025
Earl Columbus Strawn was 21 when he registered for the draft on June 5, 1917.
By Lisa Thomas October 30, 2025
Monday night I just happened to catch the last episode of this season’s “Halloween Baking Championship”—you know, the one where they have the final four bakers and one of them wins $25,000 and a feature in Food Network Magazine while everyone else goes home empty-handed?
By Lisa Thomas October 22, 2025
Years ago, a well-known celebrity lost a child when she was five months pregnant. She and her husband shared pictures of themselves holding their baby, obviously and understandably grieving their loss—and numerous people found fault with that.
By Lisa Thomas October 15, 2025
In their later years, both of my parents suffered from dementia, my father thanks to Diffuse Lewy Body Disease and my mother compliments of vascular disease which led to portions of her brain slowly dying. Two very different causes, but the same end result.
By Lisa Thomas October 8, 2025
Every December my daughter and I (and our special guest baker Tommy) gather for three very long days (plus usually one for gathering supplies) and we bake. And we bake and we bake and we bake.
By Lisa Thomas October 2, 2025
We’ve all heard the old saying “You can’t take it with you”, right? And we all know why old sayings get to be old sayings, right? (In case you don’t, it’s because there’s a grain of truth hidden in them . . .)
By Lisa Thomas September 24, 2025
It’s raining. A rare occurrence of late. And a welcome one. It’s done that off and on for the last few days, and you know what? The grass that once crunched under my feet is now soft and green again. And in need of mowing.