It Doesn't Pay To Argue

Lisa Thomas • April 24, 2024

It was 3:00 in the morning when my cell phone rang. Which is rarely ever a good thing. Maybe that’s why I bolted upright in the bed while simultaneously grabbing for the offending piece of technology. 


My mother’s voice came across the line, begging me to come to their apartment. My father was firmly convinced his good friend Callahan was fending off 40 men who were trying to storm the funeral home. He was equally insistent that the police had to be called . . . and my mother was equally insistent that they did not. 


That’s because my father was suffering from Diffuse Lewy Body Disease with dementia, an ailment that would eventually take his life and which was currently producing one fine hallucination.  And my mother, rather than playing along, was determined she would convince him that what his mind was telling him—and what he absolutely believed with every fiber of his being—wasn’t true.


I told her to tell him I was on my way (which I was), that I was calling the police (which I most certainly was not), and that they should stay inside and wait for help to arrive. When I reached the apartment, I told him law enforcement was on the scene and all the troublemakers had been arrested and hauled to jail. His main concern was Callahan (to this day, I have no idea who in my father’s past was named Callahan or if he was just a figment of Dad’s over-active imagination) and whether or not he had been injured. I assured him the gentleman was unscathed and had gone to the police station to file a full report of the very early morning’s events. And he was satisfied with my story, so much so that he went to bed and quickly fell asleep. I wish I could have done the same.


That was not our first experience with Dad’s dementia, nor would it be the last; however, no matter how hard I tried, I could never make my mother understand that arguing was useless. My father’s mind was in the process of betraying him . . . telling him outrageously unbelievable lies while providing irrefutable proof it was all true. Nothing . . . absolutely nothing she could ever say would change that. On that night he could hear the chaos. He could see the intruders. He could feel the anger of the crowd . . . and his own fear. Despite the fact there was no one storming the building, in his mind the situation was desperate, and his friend was in terrible danger while trying to protect them.


As the disease ravaged his mind and then his body, I became a master storyteller—a liar, if you will—one who could ease my father’s tortured mind by explaining away the horrible situations it created. Perhaps that’s why my phone would ring at all hours of the night. It was a talent my mother never developed. She could only see what was—and was not—before her. And she couldn’t understand why my father couldn’t understand and believe her over his own eyes.


Such is the case with anyone who has been a caregiver for a person suffering with some form of dementia. You have two options: 1) try to convince them of the truth knowing all the while it won’t help, or 2) lie. As harsh as it seems, technically that’s exactly what you’re doing. But you might also view it as creative problem solving. Or honing your storytelling skills.


It is beyond difficult watching someone you love slowly fade away. Beyond difficult when you realize you will lose them not once but twice. So, please don’t spend your last years together fighting battles you can’t possibly win. Get creative instead. Stretch your imagination and learn to walk with them through their world when necessary. As someone who can speak from experience, I guarantee you, it will go a long way toward reducing your frustration and their anger—and probably produce some really good stories . . . ones that will bring a smile to your face in the days to come.



About the author:  Lisa Shackelford Thomas is a fourth-generation member of a family that’s been in funeral s

ervice since 1926 and has worked with Shackelford Funeral Directors in Savannah, Tennessee for over 45 years.  Any opinions expressed here are hers and hers alone and may or may not reflect the opinions of other Shackelford family members or staff.


By Lisa Thomas June 18, 2025
It was dark outside when the phone rang; a glance at the clock revealed the day was still in its infancy, which explained why the funeral director’s brain did not want to engage. Years of experience prevailed however, and he answered the call, finding on the other end of the line a hospice nurse requesting their services for a death that had occurred in a home.
By Lisa Thomas June 11, 2025
In honor of the upcoming day of celebration for fathers everywhere (or at least in the United States and a few other countries), how ‘bout we look at some fun facts and/or interesting tidbits regarding the holiday and dads in general?
By Lisa Thomas June 5, 2025
It was 1972 . . . a Sunday in April when Don Price and his brother Laverne decided to go swimming at Pickwick Lake. Don was finishing up his Junior year at Central High School in Savannah and had been voted Most Athletic and Best All Around by the students there.
By Lisa Thomas May 29, 2025
The years and the connections they shared compelled her to attend the service acknowledging the end of his time on this earthly plane. There was just one problem. She had a three-year old . . . and funeral masses are usually not well tolerated by such creatures . . .
By Lisa Thomas May 21, 2025
For the past several years I’ve taken the week before Memorial Day to focus on a few members of our military who lived in our area—and who gave their lives in service to our country.
By Lisa Thomas May 15, 2025
My maternal grandmother was a fiercely independent soul, having been born and raised on a farm in the New Hope community of rural Hardin County, Tennessee. She made up for her lack of travel experiences by marrying my grandfather who worked for TVA during their years of dam construction across the southern United States.
By Lisa Thomas May 8, 2025
It was late one Saturday afternoon when the guests gathered beneath the boughs of an ancient oak. They had come to celebrate the beginning of a life together for two young people they all knew and loved, but before the ceremony began with the official seating of the grandparents and parents of the bride and groom, a woman walked down the aisle, carrying sunflowers which she gently laid in a chair at the front.
By Lisa Thomas May 1, 2025
The crowd was tremendous, numbering in the tens of thousands, and all willing to wait the almost eight hours it could take to reach their destination. And the vast majority of them came armed with cell phones and the occasional selfie stick.
By Lisa Thomas April 23, 2025
As a child I always had a love-hate relationship with Easter. I loved the egg hunts we had at school, walking to a nearby classmate’s home and searching for the elusive eggs scattered about the yard. I wasn’t crazy about being required to dress up for the church service—mainly because I wasn’t crazy about being required to dress up for much of anything.
By Lisa Thomas April 17, 2025
When a family comes to the funeral home to make arrangements for someone they have loved and lost, they come bearing much more than clothes and a picture for the memorial folder. They just don’t always realize it.
More Posts